CareCategory 08 of 9

Caregiver Registries

Definition

A caregiver registry refers screened, independent caregivers to families who need in-home help, then steps back. Unlike a home care agency, the registry does not employ the caregiver: the family typically becomes the employer, sets the schedule, and pays the caregiver directly. Families choose registries to save money and keep control, in exchange for taking on responsibilities an agency would otherwise carry.

1,000 to 2,000

US entities

18 to 30 dollars

Typical caregiver rate

15 to 30 percent

Typical savings vs agency

We estimate 1,000 to 2,000 US entities in this category. Directional estimate, not a census figure.

How they make money

Registries make money on referrals, not on hourly spread. Some charge the family an ongoing administrative fee, often folded into the hourly amount, and some charge a one-time placement fee for a long-term match. Because there is no agency layer employing the caregiver, the total hourly cost to the family usually lands meaningfully below full-service agency rates, most typically 15 to 30 percent less, while the caregiver personally earns more than an agency would pay her. That double win is the honest appeal of the model.

The costs the sticker price hides are employment costs. In most arrangements the family is the household employer: payroll taxes above the IRS threshold, workers compensation where the state requires it, and liability if the caregiver is hurt in your home. Payroll services handle the mechanics cheaply, but they only help if you use them. Families who compare a registry's rate against an agency's without pricing those obligations are comparing half the bill.

What good ones have in common

Plain about who the employer is. A trustworthy registry explains the employment model in writing before any match: who pays whom, who sets schedules, and what the family takes on. Clarity here is the whole difference between a registry and a lawsuit.

Verification you can inspect. Good registries run criminal background checks, confirm certifications and any state caregiver registry status, and check references, and they will show you the file on your specific caregiver, not a generic screening promise.

Compliant with state registry rules. A number of states license or register nurse registries and referral agencies and set screening standards for them. Where that regime exists, the registry should hold the credential and volunteer it.

A bench when your caregiver cannot come. Registries do not staff shifts, but the good ones keep enough vetted caregivers to refer a substitute quickly. Ask how backup referrals worked for real families in the last month.

Points you to payroll and insurance help. Registries that hand families a household payroll referral and a workers compensation explainer are protecting the placement. Ones that never mention employment obligations are leaving you exposed on purpose or through ignorance.

Red flags

Acts like an employer, bills like a registry. If the registry sets schedules, supervises the work, and disciplines caregivers, regulators and courts may treat someone as the employer regardless of the paperwork, and misclassification liability can land on the family. Control and the contract need to match.

Silence on employment obligations. A registry that never mentions payroll taxes or workers compensation is marketing the savings while hiding the responsibilities that produce them. The model is legitimate only when the family understands it.

Screening claims without paper. Referred means vetted only if the vetting happened. If the registry cannot produce the background check and reference results for your caregiver, assume they are forwarding names from an inbox.

Ongoing fees for no ongoing service. Some registries collect a monthly cut indefinitely while providing nothing after the match. Fees should map to what the registry still does: replacements, backup referrals, re-screening. If it does nothing, it should not keep charging.

How the category is changing

The registry model lives in a tightening regulatory squeeze. States keep sharpening worker classification rules, and several regulate nurse registries explicitly, with screening standards, disclosure duties, and lines the registry must not cross in directing care. The well-run registries have responded by leaning into the model honestly: written employer disclosures, payroll partnerships, and a clean hands-off posture on supervision. The sloppy ones drift toward acting like unlicensed agencies, which is where the enforcement actions in this category come from.

Demand keeps rising anyway, pushed by the same forces squeezing home care: agency rates climbing beyond what many families can sustain for long hours, and caregivers seeking the higher take-home pay that independence offers. Gig-style platforms have entered the space with app-based matching, effectively registries with better software, blurring old category lines. For families, the practical shift is that the savings are real and growing, but so is the paperwork, and the households doing this well now treat hiring a caregiver like the small employment relationship it legally is.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a caregiver registry and a home care agency?

An agency employs the caregiver, supervises the work, and carries payroll, insurance, and backup duties, billing you more per hour for it. A registry refers an independent caregiver and steps back: you typically become the employer, pay less, and take on those responsibilities yourself.

Who is the employer when I use a registry?

Usually you are. The family generally directs the work, sets the schedule, and pays the caregiver, which makes it a household employment relationship, with payroll taxes above the IRS threshold and workers compensation where your state requires it. Get the registry's answer in writing.

Do I need workers compensation for a caregiver?

In a number of states, household employers must carry it, and everywhere it is the protection that matters most: if a caregiver is injured lifting your parent and there is no coverage, the claim can come at your family directly. A rider or standalone policy is inexpensive relative to that risk.

How much cheaper is a registry than an agency?

Total hourly cost typically runs 15 to 30 percent below full-service agency rates in the same market, while the caregiver takes home more. Just budget for employer taxes and insurance before comparing, because those obligations are the source of the discount.

What happens if the caregiver does not show up?

The registry is not staffing the shift, so there is no dispatcher obligated to fill it. Good registries refer a vetted substitute quickly, but the reliability guarantee an agency sells is exactly what the registry model trades away. Ask how backup referrals actually work before you need one.

Want the full directory of caregiver registries?We are publishing full listings category by category. Leave an email and we will send this one when it goes live. Requests decide what publishes next.

One email per category. No newsletter.

Registries are matchmakers in a labor market, kin to staffing agencies in mechanics if not in law, and since families find them through search rather than hospital referrals, the growing ones tend to be the ones spending intelligently with marketing agencies.